Showing posts with label Discussion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Discussion. Show all posts

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Houses in collision: game of Thrones Discussion Tyrion brutality and expectation, Renly is Gay?

Now that we're halfway into the Game of Thrones season, the action has really become meaty (much like the roast venison that graces King Robert's table). In Sunday's episode, everyone gets in on the killing (even The Imp!) and there's so much intrigue to be had, the action actually stayed in Westeros the entire time. To balance out the multiple deaths and brutality, we got a whimsical helping of grotesquery thanks to original scenes written specifically for the HBO series. Shall we delve into "The Wolf and the Lion"?


TVGuide.com's Hanh Nguyen is an avid scripted-TV watcher, a horror-avoider and someone who's read George R. R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire book series, on which HBO's Game of Thrones is based. Her co-worker, Rich Juzwiak, rarely watches scripted TV, is a gorehound and became alerted to Martin's existence just recently, as he started researching this new swords-and-sandals (well, boots) series. He knows nothing of these sorcerers (if that is indeed what they are), while Hanh is something of an expert (read: fantasy/sci fi nerd). Each week, he'll try to make sense of this crazy new show by enlisting Hanh's expertise. It may turn out to be a test of tolerance: in this case, the Games begin after the TV is off.


Game of Thrones' Harry Lloyd: Viserys' wig is the secret to waking the dragon


Rich: Best episode yet!


Hanh: Yes, but what did you like in particular? I kept thinking you'd be into all the fighting and gore, but then all the weirdness at the Eyrie was pretty awesome as well.


Rich: It was action-packed, and yes, the dagger through the eye was impressive. It was a pretty bold shot of it, too — it didn't shrink away from the gore by just offering a flash of it, as this show has done often up to this point. I also love all the fetish-show stuff. A post-toddler-age child breastfeeding? Homoerotic shaving? More of that, please!


Hanh: I know! Both of those scenes brought the show to another level and differentiated it from the books. It felt very Baron Munchausen to me. I was sure Loras would cut Renly (Gethin Anthony) waaaaay before he actually did. Great suspense.


Rich: Is Renly gay in the book?


Hanh: Not that I know of! That was a surprise to me, although there have been hints he might be in the books. I don't want to spoil too much, but at one point, he does head up the Rainbow Guard. There's definitely been speculation about Renly and Loras' sexuality. I wonder how the books' fans will react.


Rich: Explain the Baron Munchausen thing because I haven't seen that movie, actually. I do know that it's farcical.


Hanh: In a way, it also felt like one of my favorite dystopian films of all time — Brazil. I'm actually referring more to the Eyrie scenes. Much of this series has felt realistic, but everything at the Eyrie is just so over the top, almost circus-like, fitting with Baron Munchausen's proclivity for telling tall tales. It's overdone and dramatic in a way that's ridiculous — you can see on Catelyn's (Michelle Fairley) face how weirded out she is.


Rich: She's freaked out by a lot. Bringing Tyrion (Peter Dinklage) to Lysa (Kate Dickie) really didn't go as expected.


Game of Thrones' Lena Headey hacks into White Collar


Hanh: How'd you like that prison? In the book the cells are also exposed to the open cliff, but I think it was more exposed and the floor is sloped down toward the cliff.


Rich: So it was a struggle just to stay on. Using the punishment of nature and physics to your advantage is torture. Ingenious torture!


Hanh: I like how this kid Robin Arryn (Lino Facioli) and Joffrey (Jack Gleeson) show just how bad the children can be.


Rich: Problem Child: The Dark Ages. Tagline: All ages are dark ages when you're a problem child!


Hanh: Here's the funny thing also: It was a good episode without going overseas for the Daenerys (Emilia Clarke) story line.


Rich: Yes! Although, that brings me to my first question for you, the expert: Why would it be so bad for King Robert (Mark Addy) for Daenerys to actually to have her child? I didn't really get what he's worried about changing. Everyone's freaking out, but it seems to me that the wheels for war are already in motion, regardless.


Hanh: If Daenerys has a boy, then King Robert is afraid that her warlord husband Khal Drogo (Jason Momoa) will then be moved to want to gain the Iron Throne back for her. So he'd bring his warriors overseas. After all, that's sort of the agreement that he has with Viserys (Harry Lloyd) — your sister for my wife, I help you get Iron Throne back. And I guess it also shows that the Targaryen line continues. Mo' Targaryens, mo' problems! King Robert is kind of consumed by hatred of all Targaryens.


Rich: I thought that Drogo was already moved to gain the throne back for her, boy or no boy. Baby or no baby, even.


Hanh: I definitely think it's a lineage issue, which is why the emphasis on the boy. I don't know if his trying to get the throne back hinges on a child, but maybe it just feels more official that way in this world where marriages and thus offspring are matters of state. If he has an heir, then he'll be moved to conquer more urgently, perhaps?


Game of Thrones' Kit Harington: "Oh God, I'm a bastard!"


Rich: Watching Bran's (Isaac Hempstead-Wright) lesson reminded me how much exposition is still happening on this show: His lesson was our lesson.


Hanh: What I thought was hilarious was how he said the Lannister motto was, "A Lannister always pays his debts."


Rich: What I thought was funny is the way he interpreted the House Tully's words ("Family, Duty, Honor"): Family comes first. The Sopranos reference was not unintentional.


Hanh: Oddly enough, the sigils and mottos aren't as explicitly explained contextually in the books like they are here on the show. Most of those things I had to read in the glossary in the back of the book. Bran is one pretty, but bitter child. I think it'd be hard to be a kid in the Dark Ages where physicality is all you really have to offer. My mind would be wasted!


Rich: And that would be a shame. The show only occasionally touches on it, but the concept of "childhood" didn't really exist back then as an acknowledged separate stage of development. Kids were just undergrown adults.
Hanh: Yeah, if you read the books, it really hits home since Dany is only 13 when she marries. It's horrifying.


Rich: I guess it'd be to scandalous to really portray that on TV.


Hanh: Yes, that would be too unsettling for our modern palate. Plus, the logistics of shooting it would be difficult.


Rich: Totally. We all saw the fuss raised over Skins!


Hanh: Dany would kick all of the Skins kids' asses!


Houses collide: Game of Thrones' Episode 4 dissected — Who is Theon Greyjoy?


Rich: I really think Arya (Maisie Williams) is a feminist character. She's so assertive of her femaleness, especially now that everyone's mistaking her for a guy.


Hanh: She is! She has not changed much from the book at all.


Rich: It almost feels like it'd be easier to pass, given the structure of that society. Like she should be taking being mistaken for a man as a compliment, but she heroically rejects it.


Hanh: Very true, and considering what kind of life she wants, who knows? She was better than Bran at all the things he was supposed to learn.


Rich: Yes. She's just unfailingly likeable.


Hanh: And her sister Sansa (Sophie Turner) — unfairly unlikeable?


Rich: Definitely, but also, I understand her submission, both in the context of her world and in the context of this story that is being told. She's the counterpoint to Arya's assertiveness. She helps explain the magnitude of Arya's breaking out of the box.


Hanh: I can't seem to find anything redeeming in her, despite the fact that she's pretty much conforming to the idea of a model child for the era.


Rich: Her attitude is very stank. And she isn't particularly sassy with it. She'd never be cast on a reality show!


Hanh: Stank, not Stark? :D


Rich: Haha, yes. Stanksa Stank.


Hanh: Right! At least give us some lip! Tyrion and Catelyn have an interesting relationship. Did you expect him to bludgeon that dude in the head with his shield? Quite brutal.


Rich: I didn't, and I loved it. Anyone can slice with a sword, but it takes a particular type of sadist to bludgeon to death with a dull object. And they do have an interesting relationship. I think it's great.


Hanh: She's become his defender in a way. Her sister is the monster. Catelyn was really naive when she captured him. It got Jory (Jamie Sives) killed!


Game of Thrones photos


Rich: When we see the whore with the kid, was that the King's or Jon Arryn's?


Hanh: I think it's implied that it's King Robert's kid. I'm trying to remember if it was actually ever said. But it has black hair, like King Robert (before he went greyish).


Rich: That was implied, but then I remembered that Littlefinger (Aidan Gillen) was supposed to take Ned (Sean Bean) to the last person who talked to Jon Arryn.


Hanh: Do you remember that blacksmith's apprentice? Another one of King Robert's by-blows. Jon Arryn had been making the rounds of Robert's various bastards before dying, and Ned can't figure out why. It's a mystery! He's like Poirot, but without the accent or insight. He's actually very un-Poirot-like. Ned is kind of floundering. He is so out of his element. I'm glad he got to pick up a sword at the end of the episode though. But of course that Lannister guard had to be all sneaky and dishonorable.


Rich: Yes, although at least he wasn't stupid enough to kill him.


Hanh: Right. Ned still has some standing with the king. It seems now Ned doesn't have any allies left at King's Landing.
Rich: Indeed. He is the Lord of Somewhere Very Far Away. Speaking of, did you have a favorite quote from this episode?


Hanh: What's yours?


Rich: "Your mother was a whore with a fat ass."


Hanh: Haha! Yes! I thought Littlefinger and Varys' (Conleth Hill) discussion about Littlefinger's brothel business was illuminating: "I'm a purveyor of beauty and discretion ... all desires are valid to a man with a full purse" or something like that.


Rich: I took that down, too. I find myself still gravitating to the earthly offerings of the show. Manipulative slow music as Ned discusses Bran's paralysis! Giant dragon skulls! Full-frontal male nudity!


Hanh: As you should be. These are definitely more of the show's contributions. Even just Jory lingering in the doorway to look at that topless whore ... at least he had a moment of pleasure before dagger in the eye! I quite like how saucy the show has become.
Rich: Me too. It's feeling less dry. It's kind of opening itself up. When Jaime (Nicolaj Coster-Waldau) showed up to confront Ned, I was with it completely. I didn't have to dissect why it was happening or why it was exciting. It just was, at long last.

Monday, May 9, 2011

Houses in collision: A game of Thrones Discussion weekly who is Theon Greyjoy?

Wouldn't it be nice if these Game of Thrones characters had "Hello, My Name Is" badges? It would certainly cut down on the confusion of who's who so we could focus on the confusion of what the hell is going on. In this week's discussion, we try to puzzle out some of the supporting characters like Theon Greyjoy, Old Nan, The Hound and the yet unseen redheaded Roz.


TVGuide.com's Hanh Nguyen is an avid scripted-TV watcher, a horror-avoider and someone who's read George R. R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire book series, on which HBO's Game of Thrones is based. Her co-worker, Rich Juzwiak, rarely watches scripted TV, is a gorehound and became alerted to Martin's existence just recently, as he started researching this new swords-and-sandals (well, boots) series. He knows nothing of these sorcerers (if that is indeed what they are), while Hanh is something of an expert (read: fantasy/sci fi nerd). Each week, he'll try to make sense of this crazy new show by enlisting Hanh's expertise. It may turn out to be a test of tolerance: in this case, the Games begin after the TV is off.


Game of Thrones' Harry Lloyd: Viserys' wig is secret to waking the dragon


Rich: When the episode opened, I thought, "This is what it sounds like when ravens deliver plot points..."


Hanh: LOL! I am not crazy about the Third Eye Blind raven either. That's a device used solely in the show, not the book. Boo!


Rich: Do ravens have any part as messengers in the books?


Hanh: Yes, they're used like carrier pigeons. So when they say, "We'll send a raven" — that's their long-distance call.


Rich: I was going to say, they could have gone with something more Hollywood if it was going to only be a convention of the show. Cans joined by strings would be more efficient.


Hanh: The raven is in the book, but just not heavy-handed dream stuff.


Game of Thrones' Kit Harington: "Oh God, I'm a bastard!"


Rich: Speaking of which, the lady that sits with Bran — who is she?


Hanh: Ah, that's Old Nan (Margaret John). She's ridiculously long-lived. She gets the people mixed up sometimes because the family names are reused. So Bran now, sometimes she thinks it's Brandon Stark, Ned's older brother who got killed.


Rich: OMG, she is me. I relate to her so hard!


Hanh: Well, you do like the gruesome!


Rich: And I get all these names mixed up! For example, I was very confused about Theon Greyjoy (Alfie Allen). I don't think I realized he's not a Stark.


Hanh: Oh yeah, because he looks like he could be, right? He looks like both Robb (Richard Madden) and Jon Snow (Kit Harington).


Rich: Yes! He looks a lot like Jon Snow...who's also not a Stark, even though he is.


Hanh: That loose, dark, indeterminate wavy hair.


Rich: But I think I've got his deal down: Ned (Sean Bean) took him in much like Jon took Ned in. Jon, uh...


Hanh: Jon Arryn, yes. Took Ned in as a ward.


Rich: So there's a similar relationship between Jon Arryn and Ned, and Ned and Theon.


Hanh: Correct, and there's something else a bit more political there also. Theon's dad was defeated in battle, so it was kind of a gesture of goodwill for the Starks to foster him as a ward. In a way though, he might be considered a hostage. So, that's why he had that interesting heart-to-heart with Tyrion, when they talked about Roz the whore. Who, by the way, wasn't in the book, but she's kind of a fun addition.


Rich: Was she on the show yet, though? Have we actually seen her?


Hanh: I guess it's not really a spoiler: You will see her.


Rich: OK.I'm just making sure I know what I saw. I swear, this show makes me feel like I'm suffering from dementia.


Hanh: Right, I don't think she's been on yet.


Game of Thrones' chilling moment: Motherly advice


Rich: I'm like, "Hi, mom!" when Catelyn (Michelle Fairley) walks on screen. You know what made me laugh?


Hanh: Which part?


Rich: The scene with Viserys (Harry Lloyd) and his "pretty little idiot" in the bathtub.


Hanh: Right!!!


Rich: She's getting turned on by all the insane dragon names, which I do not relate to.


Hanh: That whole scene is lovely and ridiculous. It's a new scene also. So you're saying you don't get turned on by dragon names? Puff would be bummed.


Rich: No! I'm too much of an old lady for that, not one of those young whores.


Hanh: You've also seen the world.


Rich: Do you think the show has a sense of humor about itself? I haven't quite decided, but your "lovely and ridiculous" comment made me think that it might?


Hanh: I think certain scenes they do. Like during this scene, I'd have to say it knows, right? (Benefit of the doubt.)


Rich: It was really, really silly, but I liked that.


Hanh: Viserys is what makes me think there's humor.


Rich: I guess everything needs comic relief. Every play needs its gravedigger.


Hanh: Viserys gets the fun lines: "What did I buy you for? To make me sad?"


Rich: Haha, yes. I also liked Tyrion's: "I have a tender spot in my heart for cripples, bastards and broken things."


Hanh: Tyrion (Peter Dinklage) is particularly well-spoken and always has that ironic tone. Love him.


Rich: Favorite line of the night, though, was from Daenerys: "The next time you raise a hand to me will be the last time you have hands" That's 2011's "Until you do right by me everything you think about is gonna crumble!" (From The Color Purple.)


Hanh: Yes, the meek little sister knows how to fashion a threat!


Rich: Do you think Daenerys' overall empowerment is a direct result of her sexual liberation? Something I'm still wrapping my head around is how she went from basically being raped by Khal Drogo (Jason Momoa) to seeming to enjoy sex.


Hanh: Hmm, I don't think it's a result per se. They do go hand in hand.


Rich: Ah. Correlative but not causal.


Hanh: Although the show makes it seem more like a cause, I just think that as the Khal's wife, she's powerful now, and seems to take to power differently from her brother.


Rich: Every time she asserts herself, "Express Yourself" starts playing in my head.


Hanh: Her platinum hair fits. And her leather top could be a boho-chic bustier.


Rich: Totally! Speaking of her brother, I don't know if I knew that his nickname was "The Dragon."


Hanh: Well, it's just the whole idea that the Targaryens are descended/related to dragons and have dragon's blood. So if he's the heir, then he could be referred to as the dragon symbolically (like the Houses with their sigils). On top of that though, I think he just has a dramatic way of speaking about his wrath ("waking the dragon" if she makes him angry). Another giggle for me. That was also in the book and Viserys was a snot there, but for some reason, I like him better on the show.


Houses collide: Game of Thrones, Episode 3 dissected


Rich: Question: Does the Watch train in Winterfell?


Hanh: No.


Rich: OK. It really looks like Winterfell to me, so I've been confused. I didn't think so, though.


Hanh: They're up north of Winterfell by the Wall at Castle Black. All snow looks alike.


Rich: Was also confused because of the Theon/Jon resemblance.


Hanh: Yeah, they need like colored headbands or something like the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.


Rich: Seriously! That would help me wrap my elderly/childish brain around this. Meanwhile, Ned's having a very time-to-make-the-donuts time over in King's Landing.


Hanh: Yeah, his life there is just wretched.


Rich: It just goes to show how the hand runs things. And the admin work is tedious!


Hanh: Oh, here's something I think is fascinating: "Snow" as a surname for a bastard. In the book, it's just the surname for bastards up north, but let's say "Stone" is the bastard surname in the Tully lands. It's handy and all, but I think it's kind of horrible that they have to be "marked" like that.


Rich: I've been wondering where Snow came from. I thought maybe it was his mother's surname, but that doesn't make sense re: the mystery surrounding his mother's identity.


Hanh: Was that clear when he talked with Samwell (John Bradley)?


Rich: I didn't get it, but that doesn't mean it wasn't clear! It's through Sam that we get to really like Jon.


Hanh: Right. Also, he's one dude who didn't sleep with Roz (Jon that is). He said he didn't want to make another bastard.


Rich: Is that who that story was about?


Hanh: Yeah. Girl gets around.


Rich: Per her job description! I thought the scene of Jon and Sam talking about sex was homoerotic, but that's me reading into it, I think.


Hanh: Normally I'd say yes, but I didn't get that vibe.


Rich: Any all-male stuff regarding sex immediately strikes me as homoerotic. Biased! Littlefinger is intriguing. I loved his "Trust me, you don't want to trust me" spiel.


Hanh: Right. Littlefinger (love that name) is oddly open about being untrustworthy.


Rich: It reminded me of the scene in Labyrinth where Sarah has to pick one of two doors and one of their guards is telling the truth and the other one is lying. And then my brain fell down a hole.


Game of Thrones photos


Hanh: Ha yes. I remember playing those mind benders as a child. You can ask only one question. I used to remember how to get around it. What did you think of why Samwell was at the wall. Did you catch his story?


Rich: Yes, he's basically the runt of his family.


Hanh: Well, not really. That's why I was upset they didn't really get the story right on the show. In the book, he's his dad's heir, and his dad is this big, warlike brute. Sam... isn't. Once the dad had a second son, he started favoring him over meek Sam. So, once Sam reached 18, it was "Go join the Watch or I'll manufacture your death." Kind of awful, but that's the lovely world they live in.


Rich: But, there is kind of a parallel between Jon taking him under his wing and Jon taking on the direwolf runt. It's interesting, the way these characters want to preserve these dynamics already established in their lives.


Hanh: Like Tyrion, Jon has a soft spot for the unwanted.


Rich: I mean, I guess that's just character consistency, but I enjoy the logic.


Hanh: Oh, was the tournament death gory enough for you?


Rich: Well, it definitely did whet my appetite. I didn't quite get where Littlefinger (Aiden Gillen) was going with what he said to Sansa (Sophie Turner) with the story of the scarred guy.


Hanh: Oh, well that another weird thing. In the book, the scarred guy —The Hound (Rory McCann) — told his own story to her, and then threatened her life if she ever revealed the story. So it was kind of a secret — he was protecting his manly rep. But if it's Littlefinger threatening her, I don't understand why he'd do that. Doesn't make sense.


Rich: The only thing I could come up with was that it was because she's going to be queen and he wanted to assert his power over her early: "Let me tell you who runs things, future runner of things..."
Hanh: It's possible?


Rich: Finally, there was the Catelyn/Tyrion showdown.


Hanh: Fun, no?


Rich: Yes. My favorite episode-ender thus far.


Hanh: They're going to have some really good Tyrion scenes coming. There's definitely humor.


Rich: It seemed like she wasn't certain at the beginning of the scene — like she went from being busted to busting.


Hanh: Right. She wanted to be all incognito, but once he called her out, she assessed the situation, how many possible allies she had. I wanted to tell her, "He's been nice to Bran!" But you know, they can't hear me. I should have sent a raven.


Rich: Believe me, I know they can't hear you. This show would be four hours long every week if they all stopped every time I said, "Wait..."


What did you think about the episode? How are you doing keeping these character names straight?